A crucial part of IPA's mission is to inform member associations and the wider global publishing community about breaking developments which will impact publishers. We do this through a number of channels. the IPA website, our monthly e-newsletter, press releases and the IPA's dedicated social media feeds.

No one expected US judge Pierre Leval or preeminent American copyright lawyer Jon Baumgarten – respective champions of the ‘for’ and ‘against’ camps in the global US-style ‘fair use’ conversation – to give ground when they squared up this month at the 2017 Charles Clark Memorial Lecture, delivered in an experimental debate-format.

Nonetheless, to publishers and other copyright watchers, this was a tantalizing prospect: the Hon. Pierre Leval, author of the April 2016 Google Books decision, trading scholarly blows with his old confrère Jon Baumgarten Esq., a stalwart IP defender and outspoken critic of the evolving fair use doctrine.

Judge Leval, America’s foremost copyright jurist and a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals Second Circuit, opened by conceding that content owners were living in ‘scary times’. The concessions stopped there, though, and he asserted that digital technologies can improve utility ‘without significant impairment’ of copyright protected rights.

Leval told the 200-strong audience of mainly copyright adherents that while the Google Books case had been protracted, acrimonious and not without controversy, his decision had been a simple one. He said the Google’s industrial-scale copying and indexing of books brought big benefits to ‘authors and the public’, did not offer a substitute for the books and did not interfere with IP owners’ right to control distribution.

He said: ‘I say to you, to an audience which I assume to be an audience of content owners and rightsholders, fair use is not your enemy; it is solicitous of your rights.’

"Fair use is not your enemy; it is solicitous of your rights."
The Hon. Pierre Leval

Taking the podium second, former General Counsel for the U.S. Copyright Office, Jon Baumgarten, parried these assertions by saying that publishers did not see fair use as their enemy, but that Google’s systematic, mass copying of books was ‘very far outside the sense, spirit, design and intendment of fair use as I have known and practiced it for over forty years.’ He also asserted that the Google Books decision overly expanded the margin to freely copy others’ works – a precedent that could potentially do significant harm to rightsholders in the digital age.

Ominously, Baumgarten then warned that ‘elements of the technology industry are promoting US-style fair use overseas’ in order to further their commercial interests, echoing comments made by 2016 Charles Clark lecturer Professor Michael Fraser, who said that powerful social forces are attacking copyright.

"Elements of the technology industry are promoting US-style fair use overseas."
Jon Baumgarten Esq.

The debate-format Charles Clark Lecture 2017, of which the IPA was a co-sponsor, was the brainchild of Paul Doda, Global Litigation Counsel for Elsevier, and the chair of the IPA’s Copyright Committee. The lecture is delivered annually under the auspices of the London-based Publishers Licensing Society (PLS) and UK Publishers Association (PA), in association with The London Book Fair.

The other co-sponsors of the event were: American Association of Publishers (AAP); Copyright Clearance Center (CCC); Copyright Licensing Agency (CLA); Federation of European Publishers (FEP); International Association of Scientific, Technical and Medical Publishers (STM); International Federation of Reprographic Rights Organizations (IFRRO); Elsevier; Harbottle and Lewis; Proskauer; Pearson; Taylor Wessing; and WIGGIN.

Click for the full transcript of the debate.

Submit to FacebookSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn

Blog

Hugo Setzer
07 November 2019
Publishing industry

October and the first days of November were again very busy, with visits to four different countries and three book fairs in the course of three weeks.

James Taylor
25 October 2019
Copyright
Publishing industry

SCCR 39 concluded this evening with an agreement found on how to keep the Exceptions and Limitations discussion moving forward and the other agenda items wrapped up and a possible new issue raised in the chamber.

James Taylor
24 October 2019
Copyright
Publishing industry

The second day of discussions on the broadcasting treaty were mainly conducted behind closed doors with the plenary chamber finally filling at 17:40 for a presentation of conclusions.

James Taylor
23 October 2019
Copyright
Publishing industry
Today’s discussions saw the focus shift from Exceptions and Limitations to the Broadcasting Treaty (and sadly not about all of the value generated by the copyright in an original work that migrates from being a book to a film, for example). The Excep...
James Taylor
22 October 2019
Copyright
Publishing industry
Educational Publishing

The first day closed with Dr Kenneth Crews waiting to be grilled by delegates and observers. He was given the opportunity this morning, but the highlights today were the side events and the ripples from some late-night messages to delegates.

James Taylor
21 October 2019
Copyright
Publishing industry
Educational Publishing
While the publishing industry was gathered in Frankfurt last week for the most important international book fair in the world, the action was already starting at WIPO in Geneva with an International Conference on Exceptions and Limitations on Friday ...
Ben Steward
01 October 2019
Freedom to publish
Book policy
Copyright
Literacy
Publishing industry

The second and final day of the IPA Regional Seminar in the Middle East was opened by Sharjah publisher Bodour Al Qasimi (Kalimat Group), who is (among other things) also the IPA Vice-President.

Ben Steward
30 September 2019
Publishing industry
When the IPA regional seminar in Amman, Jordan, got underway this morning there was a crackle of promise in the air. This was more than a conference opening – it was like the inauguration of a new bridge spanning the space between the IPA’s global me...

Press Releases campaign 2019

 

Press Releases campaign 2018

 

Newsletters campaigns 2019

 

Newsletters campaigns 2018

 

International Publishers Association

23, avenue de France
1202 Geneva, Switzerland
+41 22 704 18 20
info@internationalpublishers.org

Subscribe to our newsletter